Earlier this year, my friend
Jesse mentioned that he hadn't heard much pop music of the late 90s and early 2000s, so I set out to create a mix of the top 20 songs of the last 10 years to put onto a CD (not so cleverly titled "Nostalgia: 1995-2004"), with a goal of picking 2 songs per year.
(sidebar - I have no idea where the comma in the previous sentence should go.
Kat, can you help?)
The goal of this exercise was not to pick the best 20 songs that came out during that period, but to create, in aggregate, an homage to the pop music that most people my age remember from middle school dances, from the radio when we were learning how to drive, and the MP3s we played on Winamp while filling out our college applications. The artists selected defined the decade; one-hit wonders like Kelis were excluded (except for one - it was a bad year). Different genres, from alternative to hip hop to boy bands, are included herein. The process was an educational one - I made a list of about 50 candidate songs and asked friends to choose the ones they thought belonged on the mix CD. After getting their input, here's the final CD that I came up with, arranged in chronological order by date of album release (Song, Artist, Album, Year):
NOSTALGIA 1995-20041. "Ironic," Alanis Morissette,
Jagged Little Pill, 1995
2. "Don't Speak," No Doubt,
Tragic Kingdom, 1995
3. "Back 2 Good," Matchbox 20,
Yourself Or Someone Like You, 1996
4. "Semi-Charmed Life," Third Eye Blind,
Third Eye Blind, 1997
5. "Truly Madly Deeply," Savage Garden,
Savage Garden, 1997
6. "Pretty Fly (For A White Guy)," The Offspring,
Americana, 1998
7. "Doo Wop (That Thing)", Lauryn Hill,
The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, 1998
8. "I Want It That Way," Backstreet Boys,
Millennium, 1999
9. "All The Small Things," Blink-182,
Enema of the State, 1999
10. "Kryptonite," 3 Doors Down,
The Better Life, 2000
11. "Hanging By A Moment," Lifehouse,
No Name Face, 2000
12. "Drops of Jupiter," Train,
Drops of Jupiter, 2001
13. "Independent Women (Part I)," Destiny's Child,
Survivor, 2001
14. "She Will Be Loved," Maroon 5,
Songs About Jane, 2002
15. "Work It," Missy Elliott,
Under Construction, 2002
16. "Are You Gonna Be My Girl," Jet,
Get Born, 2003
17. "The Reason," Hoobastank,
The Reason, 2003
18. "Float On," Modest Mouse,
Good News For People Who Like Bad News, 2004
19. "American Idiot," Green Day,
American Idiot, 2004
You may notice that only one song appears for 1996; due to space constraints on the CD, I had to take off one song, which was "The Freshmen," Verve Pipe,
Villains, 1996.
Some artists who made significant contributions during that timespan were not included on the list, notably, U2, Boyz II Men, TLC, and the Red Hot Chili Peppers (whose seminal albums were released before 1994). Other artists were too similar to other artists on the list to make the CD (I lumped 'N Sync, Cristina Aguilera, 98 Degrees, and Britney Spears together with the Backstreet Boys; Franz Ferdinand and Modest Mouse's hit singles sound almost exactly the same to me). Other deserving candidates didn't make the list due to space constraints (Eminem, Jewel, Alicia Keyes, The Goo Goo Dolls, Barenaked Ladies, Linkin Park, The White Stripes, Outkast, Sublime), lack of mass popular appeal (Guster, Death Cab for Cutie), no more than one significant contribution to the decade (Incubus, Justin Timberlake, Five For Fighting, Eve 6, Ricky Martin, Coldplay [at time of the CD's creation]), or my own unfamiliarity with the artist (Almost every rapper, including but not limited to 50-cent, Jay-Z, Ludacris, Snoop Dogg, and all the ones I've never heard of).
The saddest omission of all is, of course, my own personal favorite song - "Mr. Brightside," The Killers,
Hot Fuss, 2004 - which, while hugely popular, was admittedly not as big as "American Idiot," "Float On," or Franz Ferdinand's "Take Me Out" from their self-titled album.
Comments about the list? I'd love to hear them. The one I hear most often is that "Back 2 Good" should have been replaced by "Push" from the same album.